Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anna McCormack's avatar

The thoughtful considerations and reliance on evidence in this piece couldn't stand in greater contrast to the letter sent this week by Qld's Minister for Health Shannon Fentiman to the almost 8,000 petitioners seeking an independent review of the Qld gender affirmation model of treatment. The petition we signed was presented to the Qld Parliament by MP Shane Knuth last month.

Minister Fentiman's 1 pager is full of disingenuous assertions and outright untruths. The Minister claimed, yet again, that Qld's model of gender affirming treatment is "life saving" but she was unable to provide evidence - because there is none.

Ms Fentiman also claims Qld's model of gender treatment "undergoes regular and rigorous clinical review". Again, there is no evidence of this. The Minister is attempting to create a narrative of 'move on, nothing to see here.'

The Minister then claims the Qld Gender Service is undergoing an "external service evaluation". This is untrue, the current evaluation of the gender service which is located in Qld Health is being undertaken from within Qld Health.

Throughout her 1 pager Minister Fentiman attempts to distance herself from both the service evaluation and the workings of the gender service, using terminology like "I am advised ..." and "I understand ...". In reality, Minister Fentiman has full control, and responsibility, for this evaluation, which is closed to public input and takes advice from a committee made up almost entirely of pro gender treatment people.

Expand full comment
Matt Osborne's avatar

"Testosterone is a more effective hormone than oestrogen" - wow so the results of this medical intervention differ by sex, who could have predicted

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts