6 Comments
User's avatar
Anon's avatar

Thank you again for this comprehensive round up of developments. It reads positive at least. Everything seems so…two steps forward one step back 🙏

Vincent Keane's avatar

WPATH) Standards of Care (such as SOC-8) outline general requirements for informed consent, focusing on known medical side effects like infertility and surgical risks.

They do not frame long-term elevated mortality or post-transition suicide as direct outcomes caused by transition; instead, WPATH attributes high rates of suicidality and mental health challenges to pre-existing vulnerabilities and societal minority stress.

This is word-salad nonsense:

The fact that ‘societal minority stress’ contributes to elevated suicide and mental health challenges does, in no way imply that it is not a hugely negative outcome of gender transition.

Informed consent, by definition, demands that elevated suicide is a part of informed consent, otherwise it is NOT informed.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 17
Comment deleted
Bernard Lane's avatar

True. The legal strategy is clear. Even so, I think it’s significantly different given past claims made for standards, which are heavily lent on in the absence of robust research data.

Andrew Orr's avatar

Linguistic manipulation has proven such a powerful tool to deflect argument , as illustrated by, here, in the legal domain. Perhaps it could be well employed by active professional acknowledgment of “ transgender ideation “ as an alternative , differential, diagnosis , when appropriately applied, to one of the current ubiquitous “gender dysphoria “ ?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19
Comment deleted
Heterodork's avatar

There would be a large trove of documents and public statements that go beyond opinion.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 23
Comment deleted